Elmer Crowell Early Hollow Black-bellied Plover

A. Elmer Crowell (1862-1952) East Harwich, MA, c. 1895

$16,800
Brought, including buyer's premium
Estimate $10,000–$14,000over estimate

See this lot at Copley →

SpeciesPloverConfigRigSize13.25"ConditionExcellentPaintOriginal

The catalog record

A. Elmer Crowell (1862-1952) East Harwich, MA, c. 1895 13 1/4 in. long

This exceedingly rare hollow Crowell plover, along with two other known rigmates, are the maker's earliest documented shorebird decoys. They are most likely from his personal gunning rig and used to harvest birds for both the maker's own table fare and for market. Other than these three examples, no other hollow shorebirds by the maker have surfaced. This bold plover exhibits several of the features seen in his later "dust-jacket" decoys, including a large size and fastidious attention to plumage patterns. The intricate brushwork speaks of a young man with an acute sense for detail. The flared bill tip, square "beetlehead," and long split tail show anatomical knowledge rarely matched by other makers. In excellent original paint with even gunning wear, touch-up at base of reset bill, and a hairline crack in neck.

Provenance: Joseph B. French Collection John Dinan Collection Dr. S. Lloyd Newberry Collection

Literature: Stephen B. O'Brien Jr. and Chelsie W. Olney, "Elmer Crowell: Father of American Bird Carving," Hingham, MA, 2019, p. 218, fig. A, exact decoy illustrated. Stephen O'Brien, Jr. Fine Arts, Sporting Art catalog, 2002, # 27, exact decoy illustrated.

Provenance

Joseph B. French Collection John Dinan Collection Dr. S. Lloyd Newberry Collection

Comparable sales

The 5 most recent Elmer Crowell Plovers to cross the block.

SoldConditionPaintBrought
Jul 2026Mint—$36,000
Jul 2026ExcellentOriginal$32,400
Jul 2026ExcellentOriginal$25,200
Jul 2026—Original$22,800
Jul 2026—Original$21,000

Same maker and species, most recent first. Prices include the buyer's premium. All Elmer Crowell sales