Samuel Smith Toothaker Merganser Pair

Samuel Smith Toothaker (1903-1974) Brunswick, ME, c. 1930

$9,600
Brought, including buyer's premium
Estimate $6,000–$9,000over estimate
Sold Jul 2025at Copley, July 2025

See this lot at Copley →

SpeciesMerganserConfigPairSize17.5"PaintOriginalQuantity2

The catalog record

Samuel Smith Toothaker (1903-1974) Brunswick, ME, c. 1930 17 1/2 in. long

Along with fellow Maine carver Aaron Augustus Wilson (1864-1950), Toothaker made stylish, animated gunning decoys, though his birds are far more rare. Displaying the maker's best form, this merganser pair displays inletted heads, sleek lines, and a sawtooth crest on the drake. Original paint with gunning wear. Both have tight cracks in breasts and some chips and original imperfections to wood. Hen's bill is reset.

Provenance: Frank and Vickie Schmidt Collection Jeff and Joyce Hay Collection

Literature: Gene and Linda Kangas and Donald Kirson, ed., "Bonfire of Swans," Concord, OH, 2012, p. 81, exact drake and similar hen illustrated. Paul A. Johnsgard, "The Bird Decoy: An American Art Form," Lincoln, NE, 1976, p. 80, fig. 80, exact drake illustrated.

Provenance

Frank and Vickie Schmidt Collection Jeff and Joyce Hay Collection

Comparable sales

No other Samuel Smith Toothaker Mergansers in the data yet.

Same maker and species, most recent first. Prices include the buyer's premium. All Samuel Smith Toothaker sales