Makers / Elmer Crowell / Goldeneye

Elmer Crowell Goldeneye Drake

A. Elmer Crowell (1862-1952) East Harwich, MA, c. 1905

$24,000
Brought, including buyer's premium
Estimate $25,000–$35,000under estimate
Sold Jul 2018at Copley, July 2018

See this lot at Copley →

SpeciesGoldeneyeConfigDrakeSize15.5"ConditionExcellentPaintOriginal

The catalog record

A. Elmer Crowell (1862-1952) East Harwich, MA, c. 1905 15 1/2 in. long, 6 1/2 in. wide

Hollow Crowell decoys are exceedingly rare. This example with its stunning paint is one of only a handful known to exist. Subtle intricacies of Crowell's best paint show multiple painting techniques employed, including blending to the head, pouncing to the shoulders, and cut-brush stippling to the sides, among others.

This early decoy is in a rare content or tucked-head posture. The back displays Crowell’s refined raised and carved primaries and fluted tail. The head reveals subtle rasping detail. The bottom board bears the Smith family "S” brand with "SW" representing Stanley W. Smith, Esq. (1869-1941) and "AP" representing his brother Albert P. Smith.

The Smiths were descendents of the Mayflower and their decoys are closely linked to the Willard rig of decoys found with the "JWW" brand on the bottom. The "JWW" rig was commissioned by John Ware Willard (1859-1914) who was the grandson of famous clock maker Simon Willard (1753-1848). Decoy historians Linda and Gene Kangas, in their well-researched article, "Connecting the Dots: Exploring the Provenance of Elmer Crowell's Decoys," discovered that the two owners of this decoy, Stanley Smith and Albert Smith, were close to Willard, who mentions the brothers by name in his will.

Excellent original paint with light gunning wear, some touch-up around body seam, and a reset bill.

Provenance: Stanley W. Smith, Esq. and Albert P. Smith Rig Donal C. O'Brien, Jr. Collection

Literature: Stephen B. O'Brien, Jr. and Chelsie W. Olney, "Elmer Crowell: Father of American Bird Carving," Hingham, MA, 2018, exact bird illustrated. Linda and Gene Kangas, "Connecting the Dots: Exploring the provenance of Elmer Crowell's decoys," Decoy Magazine, March/April 2010, front cover, pp.30-35, related example

Provenance

Stanley W. Smith, Esq. and Albert P. Smith Rig Donal C. O'Brien, Jr. Collection

Comparable sales

The 5 most recent Elmer Crowell Goldeneyes to cross the block.

SoldConditionPaintBrought
Jul 2026—Original$120,000
Jul 2026—Original$7,800
Jul 2026—Original$4,500
Feb 2026ExcellentOriginal$60,000
Feb 2026—Original$4,800

Same maker and species, most recent first. Prices include the buyer's premium. All Elmer Crowell sales